Reflections on White Nights by Fyodor Dostovesky
In general, I can't remember the details in the books I read. Sometimes I can't even put up the plot timelines again, let alone the details. Since I read 'Notes from the underground' I have been Dostovesky fan. That man resonated so much with me at the time, I don't think there could have been a better timing ro have read that. Learned a thing or two from there. I think that's what happens with me, even about movies. I don't remember the plot altogether, but I would have certainly internalized something from it. Recall is better with movies cause it's an audio-visual medium, but impact wise books last deeper. Just after notes I had read The Double also and after a gap of couple of years I read The Idiot last year. As such I avoid romantic plot lines, even in movies. Not just that, it may sound absurd, but I had developed an aversion to romantic songs also. I simply cannot relate to emotions those songs express. So where I do understand the lyrics (Marathi/Hindi/English) my playlist hardly contain any romantic song. I do enjoy the some old songs which were generationally pass down but no new additions have been made to the category for a looong time. The mind simply cannot accept. On the other hand, where I do not understand the lyrics (Dravidian languages and others, or English where lyrics are basically incomprehensible to naked non-native english speakers ears) I have many songs in the playlist which could be classified as romantic. Which suggests the tone and music did the trick which mind couldn't deny. So my playlist mostly contains marathi bhavgeete, bhaktigeete (this is also kind of ironic, given that I do not think myself as theist) but I do have theory for it – I guess I relate to the idea/emotion of devotion. Some patriotic songs. Across the genre in English but mostly based on music, or when I picked it up from TV or movies. Recently though there was one song which was living in my head rent free since I heard it – 'Lagel janmave punha'. This made me wonder, why am I in love with this? I never had been in any relationship, let alone the failed one. So why is this relatable at all. Is it just music/tone, nostalgicness added to the video? Why? I was discussing this with a friend, few theories came up, most were rejected. One of the outcome of the exercise was I got a suggestion to read White Nights. I was asked to see if it seems relatable. So that's how it came in the list. Being the Dostovesky fan I picked it up sooner rather than later.
Now coming to the main part, the novella is very small an avid reader can finish it in a day or two, took me more than a month so early part is all faded by now. It a love story over 4 nights and a small morning. Its hard for me to say I got some insights on life, I am again short of getting the philosophical and emotional depth here. But I have noticed few things. I can not recall any event where protagonists have described the physical beauty of their love interest. The discussion and thoughts mostly portray the longing, the need to belong. Maybe that's the point author wants to make. The protagonist is allured as dreamer (in between somewhere) probably because his unrealistic notion of love. What we go through in 4 nights slowly, somewhere hoping this idea of exquisite love makes it into possibility comes crashing at the end of 4th night, and there is no one to blame for. Or maybe the unrealistic expectations of highly effective post system (How to you expect a reply/action in 24 hrs after sending a letter? Moreso, how does a letter gets delivered by post man just over the night, and whom is it addressed to Mr. Unaproachable/Dreamer?) Maybe it is the effect of movies, that the characters behaving so thoughtfully, respectfully and sensibly feels like idealism.
“My God, a whole moment of happiness! Is that too little for the whole of a man's life?”